South Antrim drivers paying the price for £5.1m MOT contract failure – Clarke


South Antrim drivers ‘paying the price’
Ulster Unionist South Antrim Assembly candidate Liz Clarke MBE has said that the Northern Ireland Audit Office report on the Driver & Vehicle Agency's failed MOT equipment contract must lead to real accountability, after £5.1 million of public money was spent without delivering any of the promised improvements.
The Audit Office found the contract, awarded in March 2019, was ended through a negotiated settlement in April 2025 without delivering any of its intended outcomes. Around £5.1 million was spent, including £1.5 million in termination costs. The winning £10.8 million tender was 40% below the DVA's own business case estimate of around £18 million, and 53% lower than the only other compliant bid. The report found weaknesses in both the procurement process and the contract itself.
Clarke, who led public procurement portfolios worth millions of pounds, said: "This report makes for uncomfortable reading. £5.1 million of taxpayers' money is gone. Not one of the promised improvements was delivered. And motorists have been left to deal with the consequences.
"Procurement isn't about picking the cheapest bid and hoping for the best. It's about getting the specification right, testing whether a supplier can really deliver, and managing the contract properly from day one.
"A bid 40% below the Department's own estimate should have set alarm bells ringing. The lowest bid isn't always the wrong bid, but you need cast-iron assurance that it can be delivered. That assurance wasn't there. And signing a contract isn't the finish line. It's where the real work starts."
On the impact locally, she added: "In South Antrim, people depend on their cars to get to work, to school, to hospital appointments and to the airport. Around 306,000 MOT exemption certificates have been issued across Northern Ireland since 2024, and the upgrades motorists were promised may not arrive until 2029. South Antrim drivers are paying the price for a contract that should never have been allowed to fail. That's simply not good enough.
"I'm calling for four things: The Infrastructure Minister to come before the Assembly's Infrastructure Committee and explain how this contract was allowed to fail; independent assurance that the new £46 million replacement contract has the safeguards this one lacked: proper checks on unusually low bids, clear performance terms, and the power to act quickly when a supplier isn't delivering; a clear, published timetable for the MOT centre upgrades and for clearing the backlog and that the lessons of this report to be applied across every Stormont department, so the same mistakes aren't repeated elsewhere.
"Working families are paying more for everything. They deserve to know every pound they hand over is spent properly. Public money must deliver public value, and working families deserve a fair deal."