Planners put the brakes on car dealership's advertising plans


Advertising on a phone kiosk in Crumlin was also recommended for refusal
PLANNING officers have recommended putting the brakes on a car dealership's plans to light up and advertise their business.
The owners of Lochside Garages, which recently took over the old Adam H Erwin site at Ballymena Road in Antrim have proposed flood lighting, fencing and flag poles and associated site works and new flag advertising.
The Planning Committee of Antrim and Newtownabbey Borough Council was due to hear this week that twenty-five neighbouring properties were notified and no letters of objection were received, nor were there any objections from statutory consultees.
A report before the committee this week said: "The application seeks full planning permission for the erection of four flag poles, twelve floodlights, replacement and additional fencing, and associated site works at an existing car showroom and servicing facility located on the Ballymena Road, Antrim. The floodlights are proposed at an approximate height of 6m and are positioned intermittently around the site boundaries. The proposal also includes four flag poles, each approximately 6m in height, located prominently along the western frontage of the site adjacent to the Ballymena Road. The flag poles would display branded flags associated with the commercial operations of the site.
"The application site occupies a prominent roadside position on one of the principal approaches into Antrim and is viewed within a mixed-use environment comprising commercial premises, residential properties, a petrol filling station and associated roadside development. Whilst commercial signage and branding are expected within such a location, the proposed flag poles, by reason of their number, height and prominent siting along the road frontage, would introduce visually dominant vertical features that would appear excessive in the context of the existing development and streetscape.
"Following officer’s concerns regarding the height of the flag poles, amended elevations were submitted, reducing the height of the flag poles to 6m, however, the flag poles remain visually intrusive features when viewed from the public realm. Due to their scale and elevated position above the existing building frontage and boundary treatments, they would have an adverse visual impact and create a cluttered appearance along the Ballymena Road frontage.
"In summary, it is considered that the proposed flag poles fail to respect the character and appearance of the surrounding area and would not integrate satisfactorily with the established streetscape. The development would therefore fail to make a positive contribution to local character and distinctiveness. The floodlighting and fencing elements of the proposal, in isolation, are considered acceptable in terms of design and appearance; however, the adverse urban design impacts arising from the flag poles are such that the proposal as a whole is unacceptable."
"Overall, it is considered that the proposal would not result in an unacceptable adverse impact on the residential amenity of neighbouring occupiers by reason of overlooking, loss of privacy, overshadowing, dominance, noise, light pollution or other forms of disturbance. Given the nature of the proposal, it is not expected to generate additional traffic, parking demand, or servicing requirements. The existing access and parking arrangements are considered sufficient to accommodate the development and there are no road safety concerns arising from the proposal."
The report concluded: "The proposal is considered unacceptable in terms of siting, scale, massing, design and appearance. The proposal is considered acceptable in terms of neighbour amenity; the proposal is not considered to result in adverse impacts on trees and the environmental quality of the area; the proposal is not considered to negatively impact amenity space, or parking and manoeuvring; and the proposal is not considered to have a significant adverse impact as a result of surface water flooding."
A subsequent report said: "The application seeks advertisement consent for advertisements on four proposed flag poles which is the subject of a concurrent application which includes flood lighting, fencing and associated site works. The proposal includes four flag poles, each approximately 6m in height, located prominently along the western frontage of the site adjacent to Ballymena Road. The flag poles would display branded flags associated with the commercial operation of the site. Given their height, number and prominent position along a main road frontage, the proposed advertisements would be highly visible within the public realm and would form a dominant feature when viewed from the Ballymena Road and the surrounding area.
"The cumulative effect of four branded flags displayed on freestanding flag poles would result in an overly prominent and visually intrusive form of advertising that would add unnecessary visual clutter to the site. It is considered that the scale and prominence of the proposed advertisements would detract from the visual amenity of the area and fail to integrate satisfactorily with the character and appearance of the surrounding streetscape. The advertisements are therefore not considered to be sympathetic to their location."
DfI Roads was consulted and responded with no objection and did not identify any concerns regarding the impact of the proposed advertisements on the safety or free flow of traffic on the adjoining road network.
However planning officers recommended refusal, saying that 'the principle of development cannot be established', adding: "The proposed advertisements, by reason of their number, height and prominent siting on four freestanding flag poles along the Ballymena Road frontage, would result in an unduly prominent and visually intrusive form of advertising. The cumulative impact of the advertisements would create visual clutter and detract from the visual amenity, character and appearance of the surrounding area."
Meanwhile, refusal is also being recommended for a digital advertisement unit in Crumlin. New World Payphones has applied for the structure on Main Street.
Four letters were received, with concerns about impact on residential amenity given the siting outside residential properties, an increase in anti-social behavior, the unsuitable location of the proposal, an impact on the appearance and character of the area, obstruction of footpath, lack of need for the proposal and noise and light pollution concerns.
The application seeks advertisement consent for a digital display screen on the eastern elevation on a proposed telephone kiosk, which is the subject of a concurrent application.
A report said: "In this case, it is noted that the kiosk has been recommended for refusal by officers and as such, the principle of development for the proposed advertisement cannot be established without full planning permission being granted for the kiosk to which it relates. Moreover, the application site is located approximately 3m from No. 90 Main Street and other neighbouring residential properties. It is considered that the proposed advertisement would negatively impact upon visual amenity of the residential area.
"Accordingly, the proposed advertisement is not considered acceptable at this location, owing to the recommendation for refusal of the concurrent application to the kiosk to which the advertisement relatesand its position directly adjacent to residential properties.
"The proposed telephone kiosk takes an ‘L’ shape form. The digital display unit is on the eastern elevation and measures approximately 1.6m in height and 0.9m in width. The advertisement would portray static advertising images in sequence, changing every 10 seconds.
"The proposed advertisement is located 3m from No. 90 Main Street which consists of a residential bungalow, with other bungalows located to both the north and south of this property. It is considered that the LED illuminated signage when viewed in the context of the surrounding area would have a significant detrimental impact upon the visual amenity and character of the area given its position in close proximity to residential properties.
"The proposed advertisement is not considered to be compatible with this area which is largely residential along this stretch of Main Street with the commercial and retailing uses associated with the Town Centre being located further to the north of Main Street. The proposal is therefore considered to detract from the visual amenity of the area.
"Concerns were raised through letters of objection in relation to noise and light pollution as a result of the proposal. The council’s Environmental Health Section was consulted on the proposal and offered no objection to the proposal, subject to a condition regarding luminance levels.
"Whilst no concerns were raised from the council’s Environmental Health Section, there are concerns with the impact the proposal would have visual amenity and outlook of the occupiers of nearby residential properties, particularly 88 Main Street, given the proposed siting of the advertisement on the southern elevation and approximately 3.5m from the window to the front of this property. It is therefore considered that the proposal will have an unacceptable adverse impact on neighbour amenity
"Concerns were raised through letters of objection that the proposal would obstruct pedestrians on the public footpath. It is noted that the kiosk replaces an existing planter, however, it does not take up the entire width of the footpath and would not significantly obstruct movement. The proposal does not impact upon existing parking or access arrangements along Main Street and DfI Roads were consulted on the proposal and offered no objection subject to conditions. As such, the proposal is not considered to prejudice road safety.
"It is considered that the proposal will not obstruct or pose any distraction to road users and overall will not prejudice public safety."
Concerns were raised through letters of objection that the proposal would result in anti-social behaviour within the area. However the report said: "No evidence has been submitted to determine that the proposed advertisement would result in any increase in anti-social behaviour or loitering. In addition, concerns were raised about a decrease in property values as a result of the proposal. It is considered that this issue should not be afforded weight in the determination of this application."
Officers recommended refusal for advertising consent, in that the proposal would not improve environmental conditions or make a positive contribution to the area and is not compatible with the adjacent residential land uses along Main Street, Crumlin. It was also said that the proposal would have a detrimental impact on the visual amenity, privacy and outlook of the existing residential properties.