Two industrial units earmarked for approval, despite objections


There were nine letters of objection from five properties
TWO industrial units in Antrim have been earmarked for planning approval despite local objections.
At the Planning Committee meeting of Antrim and Newtownabbey Borough Council this week, elected members are due to heat proposals for two light industrial (Class B2) units, roof mounted solar panels, parking, landscaping, access onto Kilbegs Road and ancillary works and lands 25m North of 8 Kilbegs Road, Antrim, BT41 4NN
There were no objections from statutory consultees, but nine neighbouring properties were notified of the application, and nine letters of objection have been received from five addresses.
Concerns included overlooking and loss of privacy, dominance, overshadowing, noise, vibration and other forms of disturbance, impact on physical health from construction related activities which would affect air pollution and air quality, the reliability of the Noise Impact Assessment methodology and conclusions and visual impact of the proposal development marring the distinction between industrial lands and countryside.
There were also concerns about views of the proposed development in the winter months, potential for surface run off to enter Lough Neagh, insufficient visibility splays are not sufficient, lack of parking for the proposed development, an increase in traffic from the
Class B2 use which covers any industrial process which can be carried out without detriment to amenity by reason of noise, vibration, smell, fumes, smoke, soot, ash, dust or grit.
A report before the committee said: "The application site is located within the settlement limit of Antrim, to the north of Kilbegs Business Park, and northwest of a Tesco Distribution Centre and The Junction. Lands to the south of the application site are predominately non- residential, characterised by storage and distribution, light industrial, and retail land uses.
"Lands to the north of the application site are characteristically residential, with the Carnbeg residential development located on the opposite side of the Kilbegs Road to the northwest of the application site. The application site has a direct access onto the Kilbegs Road, and from here, it can easily access the M22 motorway which links to the M2 and the A6.
"The two proposed units are single storey, with a ridge height of 7 metres to floor level, and a footprint of approximately 133sqm each. The units are positioned towards the rear boundary of the application site and either side of the new access. Other units in the surrounding area fall within use Class B2 for example, a coffee roaster, machine maintenance service and manufacturers of compressed air products. Given the context of the surrounding area, the nature of
"The development also includes solar roof panels, thereby integrating sustainable energy measures. All four boundaries of the site will be defined by a new dark green, 2.4-metre-high mesh panel fence. The Proposed Site Layout Drawing shows the retention of existing hedging along the northern boundary; this is positioned in front of the new fence, which will contribute to its integration and lessen any visual impact of the proposed development. A new native hedge will be planted behind the boundary fence along the eastern boundary, whilst all other existing vegetation and trees on the application site will be retained. "
The report said that bat and bird boxes would be mounted on existing trees to promote biodiversity.
It continued: "The council’s Environmental Health Section (EHS) has assessed both the Noise Impact Assessment and the additional information. EHS has also taken into consideration the points raised in a number of objection letters in relation to the impact of noise generated by the proposed development on neighbouring amenity. EHS is satisfied that the amenity at nearby sensitive receptors can be protected subject to the attachment of suitably worded conditions including a restriction on operating hours, delivery hours and the submission of a Noise Management Plan.
"A number of objectors also raised concern with the proposed development impacting on their amenity by way of overlooking, loss of privacy, dominance and overshadowing. The residential properties are located to the north of the application site and given the movement of the sun, from east to west, there is the potential for overshadowing in the late afternoon / evening. However, there is a separation distance of around 55 metres from the side elevation of the proposed units to the existing dwellings in Carnbeg, and it is considered that over this distance, the potential for overshadowing is greatly reduced.
"The separation distance between the proposed units and the dwellings in Carnbeg is considered sufficient to ensure that the residents do not feel ‘hemmed in’ by the units; and with this separation distance of approximately 55 metres, the proposal will not dominate outward views from the residential properties. Furthermore, the Kilbegs Road runs parallel to the northern boundary of the application site and the southern boundary of the Carnbeg development, with this latter boundary defined by a wide roadside grass verge, and a row of mature trees. It is considered that this intervening vegetation and the public road further offset any potential for dominance.
"It is also considered that due to the separation distance, existing residents will not be significantly impacted by way of overlooking or loss of privacy. Furthermore, the units are positioned on the site with the side elevation to the northern boundary and the Carnbeg residential development. This elevation contains only a ground floor window and door. The northern boundary of the site is currently defined by a row of hedging, which is to be retained, whilst along the outer boundary of the Carnbeg development is a row of mature trees. It is considered that this existing vegetation will further restrict any views into residential properties.
"Objectors have stated that this row of trees along the outer boundary of the Carnbeg development are seasonal, and during the winter months, views of the proposed development would be possible. It is acknowledged that there may be some intermittent views of the new development from the nearest residential properties, however, the planning system operates in the wider public interest and not for the protection of private views.
"There have also been concerns raised regarding the impact on the physical health of nearby residents from construction related activities which would affect air pollution and air quality. Whilst it is acknowledged that construction works can give rise to temporary effects such as dust, emissions from plant and machinery, and increased vehicle movements, these impacts are generally short-term in nature. The outline Construction Environmental Management Plan sets out the control measures to deal with noise and vibration, dust and emissions, and these are considered sufficient to ensure there is no detrimental impact on neighbour amenity from construction related activities which would have the potential to affect air pollution and air quality.
"Given that any construction-related effects would be temporary, localised to the application site, and subject to mitigation and regulatory controls, it is considered unlikely that the proposed development would result in any significant adverse impacts on air quality or the physical health of nearby residents. Furthermore, there is no evidence to indicate that the scale of the proposed development would give rise to any unacceptable air quality effects that would warrant refusal of planning permission.
"The proposed development is sufficiently separated from residential dwellings and will not give rise to issues of loss of privacy, dominance or overshadowing, and it is considered that the proposed development will not have any significant impact upon residential amenity."
In terms of access and parking, the report continued: "Objectors have stated that the visibility splays shown on the submitted drawings are not sufficient for the development proposed, however, DfI Roads was consulted with the application and are content with the access arrangements.
"The applicant has submitted auto track drawings to show how refuse vehicles and a fire engine could access the site, although it has not been demonstrated how HGV deliveries could be accommodated within the site and DfI Roads has advised that the Planning Section should consider a condition for no articulated HGV deliveries to the site as it has not been demonstrated by the applicant as achievable. A condition has been recommended at the end of this report in relation to HGV vehicles.
"Objectors have raised concerns with the number of parking spaces being provided, stating that this number is not adequate to serve the proposed development. The proposed units have a total floorspace of approximately 268sqm, and in accordance with parking standards, a total of 11 non-commercial parking spaces are required, as well as a minimum of one commercial parking space. The Proposed Site Layout shows 13 parking spaces, of which two are van spaces located at each proposed unit and is considered sufficient.
"An objector considers that parking for the proposed units should be assessed on an individual basis, and that a floorspace of 134sqm for each unit equates to 5.36 parking spaces, which when rounded up and added together, would give a total requirement of 12 non-commercial and two commercial parking spaces. Calculating the parking requirement on this basis results in one extra space above what the applicant is currently proposing. The application site is located within the development limits of Antrim and can be accessed via alternative means aside from a private car. However, whilst the calculation indicates that one additional parking space would be required compared to that proposed by the applicant, this shortfall is not considered sufficient, in itself, to warrant refusal of the application."
Part of the proposed site boundary fencing would be within the 1 in 100 year fluvial and 1 in 100 year fluvial (Climate Change) floodplains of Holywell Burn, however, the report said that the applicant has since amended this part of the proposed development so that it now lies outside the extents of the floodplains.
The report said: "DfI Rivers has reviewed the amended Site Layout Plan and is content with the development. Given the size and type of development proposed, a Drainage Assessment would not be required in this case, however, one has been submitted with the application. DfI Rivers has assessed the Drainage Assessment, concluding that the applicant has provided a sufficient drainage design supported by adequate calculations, maintenance plan and storm water discharge approval from Rivers Directorates local area office. Therefore, while not being responsible for these proposals and associated information, DfI Rivers indicates that they agree with the applicant’s logic and have no reason to disagree with their conclusions.
"DfI Rivers reservoir inundation maps indicate that the application site is in a potential area of inundation emanating from the Lower Potterswalls Reservoir, and that it has not been demonstrated to DfI Rivers that the condition, management and maintenance regime of Lower Potterswalls Reservoir is appropriate to provide sufficient assurance regarding reservoir safety. However, in relation to this site, DfI Rivers has carried out an assessment of flood risk to people (based on the Defra / Environment Agency’s “Hazard to People Classification using Hazard Rating”) for an uncontrolled release of water emanating from Lower Potterswalls Reservoir.
"The overall hazard rating at this site is considered as low/moderate, and in the event of an uncontrolled release of water there will be risk to some including children, the elderly and infirm; as these groups can be more vulnerable to risks associated with flood water. It is noted that the proposed development is for light industrial units and does not involve any of the more vulnerable groups listed above. In this regard, and as the overall risk at this site is low / moderate, DfI Rivers considers it to be acceptable."
The report said that the application site is hydrologically linked to Lough Neagh and Lough Beg.
It continued: "Natural Environment Division (NED) are satisfied with the mitigation measures proposed to prevent pollution pathways to the adjacent watercourses. NED are content that any potentially significant impacts on the designated sites will be avoided if the methods and mitigation measures provided are adhered to, unless there are any significant changes.n Shared Environmental Services (SES) indicated in its consultation response that the project would not have an adverse effect on the integrity of any European site either alone or in combination with other plans or projects, subject to the implementation, and adherence to, the mitigation measures to effectively prevent the egress of contaminated water from the construction site.
"NED noted that the site consists mainly of an area of semi-improved grassland with rows of semi- mature trees to the north and south. NED indicated that they are satisfied that all trees within the site area were assessed as possessing ‘negligible’ Bat Roost Potential. NED also noted that there was no evidence of other species, such as otter or badgers, although a mammal path was recorded in southeast of the site, travelling from the grassland habitat into the scrub.
"NED welcomeed mitigation measures, such as soil ramps, to prevent injury or entrapment of foraging mammals within excavations required for the proposal.
"Finally, NED highlighted that no details of proposed external lighting for the proposal have been included within the submitted information and were satisfied that impacts from lighting are not likely, provided that lighting is restricted to security lighting at the front entrances of both structures and directed towards the centre of the site."
NI Water was consulted with the proposed development and raised no objection, however, has advised that a 600mm trunk combined sewer traverses the site and stated that the associated wayleave is not identified on the submitted drawings.
The report said: "A Proposed Drainage Layout General Arrangement drawing within the Drainage Assessment does show the combined sewer and the proposed relocation of it. The realignment of this sewer may be required and an application should be made to NI Water to carry out such works. NI Water can make an assessment of whether the realignment of the sewer is acceptable and then decide to grant or refuse consent to divert the sewer. The role of the planning system is not to duplicate the regulatory controls of other statutory bodies and matters which lie outside the control of planning should not form part of the decision-making process, unless it is demonstrated that the development would result in adverse impacts on the environment. In this case, the adverse impacts that could arise from the development include the potential to adversely affect wastewater infrastructure, resulting in pollution, increased flood risk and impacts on water quality, and restricted access for inspection, maintenance and repair. Provided that no development could commence until such times as the necessary agreement was obtained, then no adverse impacts would arise. This is a matter which could be negatively conditioned should planning permission be forthcoming and therefore a reason for refusal on this issue could not be sustained.
Planning officers recommended planning approval, saying that the principle of the development, design and appearance of the proposed development is acceptable and that the proposed development will not have an unacceptable impact on thevisual appearance of the area; will not result in an unacceptable impact on neighbour amenity and that there are no concerns relating to access, parking and road safety matters.
They also said that the proposed development will not lead to an increase in flood risk; and there will be no detrimental impact on designated sites, protected species, or priority habitats and species.